Dark Window

Your astrophotography copilot

Types of astrophotography compared

Milky Way landscapes, tracked wide field, deep sky and planetary imaging all point a camera at the night sky, but they need different gear, different exposures and different habits. Here they are side by side, so you can see where each one starts and which suits your sky, budget and patience.

Side by side

The figures are typical ranges, not rules. A good result is possible outside them.

Milky Way wideWide fieldDeep skyPlanetary
The subjectThe Milky Way arching over a landscape.Big nebulae, star fields, Andromeda, constellations and the Milky Way without a foreground.Individual nebulae, galaxies and clusters in detail.Jupiter, Saturn, Mars, Venus and the Moon.
Lens or telescopeA 14 to 35 mm lens, fast (f/1.4 to f/2.8).A 50 to 300 mm lens, or a small refractor around 200 to 400 mm.A telescope of about 300 to 1500 mm focal length.A telescope with 2000 mm or more focal length, using a Barlow.
CameraA mirrorless or DSLR camera.A mirrorless or DSLR camera, or a small astro camera.A cooled astro camera, or a modified DSLR.A small, fast, uncooled planetary camera.
MountA tripod. A tracker is optional.A star tracker or a small equatorial mount.A solid equatorial mount, usually with autoguiding.A tracking mount. No guiding.
Exposure per frameAbout 10 to 25 seconds on a tripod, or minutes with a tracker.30 seconds to a few minutes, tracked.1 to 10 minutes, tracked and guided.Milliseconds, recorded as video.
Total time on targetAbout 5 to 30 minutes, or a blend of foreground and sky.30 minutes to a few hours.Several hours, often many nights.A few minutes of video per planet.
Dark sky mattersVery much. The Milky Way fades quickly with light pollution.Yes, though filters help with nebulae.Yes, and narrowband filters help from town.Hardly at all.
Moon mattersYes, shoot when it is down.Yes, for broadband targets.Yes, for faint targets. Narrowband tolerates it.No.
Polar alignmentNot needed on a tripod. Rough for a tracker.Rough to good.Accurate, and checked.Rough.
ProcessingLight: stack the sky, blend the foreground, adjust contrast and color.Calibrate, stack, stretch and clean up gradients.The full route: calibrate, stack, gradient removal, stretch, color, noise and star control.Stack the best frames, then sharpen with wavelets.
Rough cost to startLow. A camera and tripod you may own already.Moderate. Add a tracker.High. Telescope, mount, camera, guiding and a computer.Moderate. A telescope you have, plus a camera and Barlow.
DifficultyEasiest to begin.Easy to moderate.Hardest to get right.Moderate, with a steep finish.

Milky Way wide

This is the landscape side of astrophotography: a wide, fast lens, a tripod, and a dark foreground under the Milky Way. Because the sky turns, a tripod exposure has to stay short, or the stars become short trails. A common starting point is 15 to 20 seconds at f/2.8 with a 20 mm lens, then you check the stars at full size. The longer the lens, the shorter the exposure you can use. Many people take several frames and stack the sky to cut noise, and shoot the foreground separately.

Wide field

Wide field means tracked exposures with a short lens or small refractor, so you frame an entire region of sky: Orion, the Heart and Soul nebulae, the Rosette, Andromeda with its neighbors, or a stretch of Milky Way with no foreground. A star tracker lets exposures run for minutes, so far fainter detail appears than on a tripod. Alignment must be reasonably good, but guiding is often skipped.

This is the best bridge into deep sky. You learn tracking, stacking and stretching with forgiving gear. Use the FOV calculator to see which targets fit your lens, and read the calibration frames guide and the processing guide.

Deep sky

Deep-sky imaging uses a telescope to show a single nebula, galaxy or cluster in detail. Targets are faint, so the work is about collecting enough light: long exposures, many of them, over many nights, with a mount that tracks precisely. It has the most equipment, the most steps and the biggest payoff, and it is the most affected by your sky and the Moon. Filters, calibration frames, guiding and a careful stretch all matter.

Planetary

Planetary imaging turns the usual rules upside down: very long focal lengths, exposures of milliseconds, video instead of stills, and light pollution that hardly matters. Instead of fighting a faint signal, you fight the shimmer of the atmosphere, and processing is about choosing the best frames and sharpening them. It suits bright skies, a bright Moon and short evenings. Read the photographing planets guide for the details.

Which one is for you?

The types share a lot of the same skills: focusing, reading the histogram, stacking, and learning to read the weather and the Moon. Time spent on one carries over to the others.

A natural path

  1. Start with the Milky Way on a tripod to learn exposure, focus and the sky.
  2. Add a star tracker for wide field, which teaches tracking, calibration and stacking.
  3. Move to a telescope and an equatorial mount for deep sky, adding guiding and filters as the targets demand.
  4. Try planets and the Moon whenever the sky is bright or the Moon is up. They need only the telescope you already have, plus a small camera and a Barlow.

You do not need to follow it in order. Plenty of people never leave one type, and a good picture in any of them is hard to take.

Open the Dark Window planner to check tonight’s sky.

Free, no ads. A tip or a shirt covers hosting and keeps updates coming.